Stick #64
Moderately Good孟之反奔
Meng Zhifan's Retreat
In face of danger, Mencius was the last to run.
He was highly praised for what he had done.
Modestly smiling, he refused the honour for bravery; Said his horse wouldn’t go was the true story.
Asking about: Wealth
The Story Behind This Stick
This story comes from the Analects of Confucius, around 484 BCE. Meng Zhifan was a general of the state of Lu during a battle that went badly. His army broke and ran. In retreats like this, the position at the very back — the rear guard — is the most dangerous spot. Everyone wants to be in front, closer to safety. Meng Zhifan stayed at the back, covering his fleeing comrades, right where enemy arrows landed first.
When he finally rode through the city gates, people cheered him as a hero. He could have taken the praise. Instead he whipped his horse and laughed it off: "I wasn't being brave. This stubborn horse just wouldn't go any faster."
Confucius recorded this moment because it captured something rare — a man who did the hard, thankless thing and then refused to turn it into status. In a culture where reputation could make or break a family's future, deflecting glory was almost unheard of.
The stick carries his energy: quiet competence, no showboating, wealth that grows when you stop needing the applause that usually comes with it.
Here's what this stick is telling you about money: you're probably doing better than you give yourself credit for, and the real question is whether you can hold your ground without needing everyone to notice.
Moderately Good in the wealth column almost always means the same thing. Income is steady. The water in the well hasn't dropped. But there's usually a leak somewhere, and with this particular sign, the leak tends to be ego-shaped.
Think about Elena, 34, a graphic designer we spoke with in Lisbon. She was earning well — better than she'd ever earned. But every time a client praised her, she'd immediately discount her next invoice, or throw in extra revisions for free. She couldn't sit with being valued. Meng Zhifan deflected glory after the battle was already won. Elena was deflecting it before the payment cleared. Big difference.
That's the trap this stick points to. You might be spending to look modest, under-charging to seem reasonable, or turning down opportunities because claiming them feels immodest. The old poem praises Meng Zhifan for refusing honour — but read it carefully. He took the dangerous post first. The humility came after the work was done and paid for.
On earned income, the outlook is genuinely okay. Patient work, existing clients, the slow harvest from seeds planted last year — this is where your treasury fills. Keep tending it.
On windfalls, shortcuts, and get-rich-quick routes, the stick is clearly warning you off. "Fame and wealth are not to be attained" in the traditional reading means stop reaching for the dramatic win. Plans for speculative moves should wait. The door isn't open there right now.
Our take: this is a year for quiet accumulation, not headlines. The horse isn't refusing to run because it's weak. It's refusing because this isn't the terrain for sprinting.
What To Do Next
Before the next lunar new year, do one unglamorous audit: list every recurring expense you kept because it signals something about who you are, rather than because you actually use it. Cut two.
This autumn, practise receiving. When someone praises your work or offers to pay you properly, say thank you and stop talking. No discount, no hedge, no "oh it was nothing."
Guard your core income like it's the rear guard — that's where the real value sits. Delay any big speculative moves or career gambles until after spring. Ride out this season on the existing field.
Watch for one pattern: are you keeping yourself small to stay likeable? If yes, that's the hidden drain this stick wants you to see.
Your income is fine. The leak is ego-shaped — you're underselling yourself to seem modest.
What you feel reading this is already part of the answer.
Next, tell us your situation for a personalized reading.
Ask a QuestionShare your situation for a more accurate reading
Recommended Articles
Further Reading
FAQ
- Is Stick #64 (Moderately Good) good or bad?
- "Moderately Good" is a middle-tier fortune. It suggests your situation has room for growth but requires attention and direction. The real value is in the specific guidance — fortune sticks are tools for self-reflection, not prediction.
- How accurate is Wong Tai Sin Stick #64 for wealth?
- Fortune sticks work as a mirror for self-reflection rather than prediction. If the interpretation resonates with you, that's the stick doing its job — revealing what you already sense but haven't articulated.
- Is Wong Tai Sin accurate for money questions?
- Not the way a stock forecast is accurate. A fortune stick won't tell you next month's earnings or which asset to hold. What it does — when it works — is surface the thing you're not saying out loud: that you're spending to feel secure, or chasing shortcuts because the patient path feels too slow, or haven't separated steady income from speculative side bets. "Accurate" here means "clear." If reading the interpretation changes how you see your relationship with money, that's the stick doing its job.
- What should I do if I drew a bad wealth fortune stick?
- A "Poor" wealth stick is blocking speculative routes, not your real path. Concrete steps: (1) hold your main income line — don't switch jobs or chase new ventures under pressure; (2) find the leaks in your spending — expenses driven by image, social comparison, or buying emotional safety; cut them before the next season change; (3) build goodwill — help where you can, honor old commitments. These rebuild the ground you stand on. The value of a Poor stick isn't in what to avoid — it's in what becomes clear when you stop pretending.
- Can I draw fortune sticks for the same question again?
- Traditionally, you should ask about the same matter only once. Drawing repeatedly often means you're seeking the answer you want rather than the guidance you need. To explore different angles, try a different life topic for the same stick number.